Response to KARA id 34022 and clarification of the truth

[Honordrius]

Hello,

I would like to respond to the penalty here:

https://forum.moonwell.su/topic/2565-kara-id-34022/

Raid Karazhan id 34022 was composed and led by the nick "Fusk", who warned that each player can only roll items into one specialization. He wrote this several times during the raid and gave himself master loot for each boss and distributed the items. I chose the holy specialization for the rolling option, but since I have this equipment insufficient for the raid, I was forced to play the protection specialization most of the time, but when I could, I played the holy specialization (see screen 1.). During the entire raid, I passed almost all items, because they were better for healers for certain classes (cloth, leather and possibly mail). For tanking items, it was especially for the feral druid.

Then the whole raid came to the "Chess Event" and there the leader "Fusk" selected the entire loot through the master loot without warning and without announcing the roll, and it was specifically [Triptych Shield of the Ancients] (heal shield) and I think [Heart-Flame Leggings] (heal leggings). (screen 2, but without direct evidence). Leader "Fusk" ordered me to continue tanking and gave us only a few more attempts on the boss "Prince Malchezaar" and then left the raid. Players were constantly leaving the raid and the composition of the raid was constantly changing, so I got the "raid leader" rank and I was able to successfully complete this raid. (see screen 3).

The loot from the boss was:

[Helm of the Fallen Defender] (token war, priest, druid)

[Ruby Drape of the Mysticant] (spell back)

[Light's Justice] (heal mace)

As a replacement raid leader, I followed all the previous looting rules that I had noted from the original leader "Fusk" and acted according to my best knowledge and conscience.

The original raid leader, nickname "Fusk" explicitly prohibited the possibility of rolling for multiple types of specialization from one boss.

I divided the loot in this style:

T4 token passed to the highest roll. Item [Ruby Drape of the Mysticant] (spell back) - highest roll nick "Kinkeid" (see screan 4). Item [Light's Justice] (heal mace) roll 98 nick "Kinkeid", but because he rolled and got the item (spell back) specifically for another specialization, he lost this option (chance). The next and only roll 80 was for nick "Honordriuss", so this [Light's Justice] (heal mace) could go fairly and according to the raid rules only here.

I would like to emphasize that nick "Kinkeid", who wrote the previous complaint, manipulated the evidence very well so that it looked in his favor and the whole story and therefore the truth could not be seen! There are a lot of injustices in the world, so I would be grateful and happy if at least in this game justice was ensured if players violate it.

Please return me the item [Light's Justice]

and enable loot from "Chest (Chess Event)" from this past ID.

Sorry for the delay, but please solve it!!!

Thank you in advance for solving it and have a nice day

Honordrius

[Burning]

Hello @Honordrius,

Thank you for your response.

For each new raid, the following loot distribution rules apply by default: you can roll on everything except items that do not fit your current spec or are useless for your character. The raid leader has the right to establish other rules (for example, reserve certain items or allow rolling for another spec), but must notify all raid participants in advance in raid chat. 

2026-02-23 12:43:33 - Raid started time.
2026-02-23 12:56:11 #34022 [BOSS KILL] name: Attumen the Huntsman entry

2026-02-23 12:57:17 #34022 [Fusk]->RAID_WARN:[Fusk,Flashback,Morghul,Honordriuss,Mystic,Ashen,Dopelsoldner,Revelion,Судорога,Гонорея] Spectral Band of Innervation rroll ms
2026-02-23 12:57:19 #34022 [Honordriuss]->ROLL:1-100 = 2 (class: Paladin, spec: 0/47/13) - Protection Paladin.

We would like to draw your attention to the following points:

• Your specialization at the start of the raid was Protection Paladin.
• There is no record of you or raid-leader [Fusk] announcing a roll for Healer (Holy) spec in the raid chat logs.
• Spectral Band of Innervation is suited for Protection or Holy Shock Paladin, but not for a Healer (Holy), and you have rolled that item.

Regarding [Kinkeid] and [Ruby Drape of the Mysticant]:
He believed it was acceptable to roll for two specializations; however, this has already been explained in his topic - such behavior is not permitted. Since [Kinkeid] entered the raid as a Restoration Shaman, his main spec is considered Healer. As the Raid-Leader in the moment of "Prince Malchezaar", you should have instruct him to wait for the off-spec roll phase before you granted him the item Ruby Drape of the Mysticant.

However:

17 часов назад, Honordrius сказал:

I chose the holy specialization for the rolling option, but since I have this equipment insufficient for the raid, I was forced to play the protection specialization

Could you please clarify how you chose the Holy specialization for rolling? Where and when exactly was this stated?
Or, if you were indeed forced to change your specialization as you mentioned, could you provide more details of this forcing?